Fitbit surge vs fitbit blaze

Fitbit Blaze vs. FitBit Surge

With a large market following, Fitbit is the indisputable market leader in the fitness tracking domain. Therefore, it`s only natural that we compare two of their best fitness watches: Fitbit Blaze vs. Fitbit Surge.

Blaze and Surge are reasonably similar. Both are fitness watches but not precisely smartwatches. Similarly, both are solid and reliable.

However, they both have their limitations, and in this comparison review, we shall look at what separates them, and what each has to offer. Ultimately, our guide will allow you to make an informed choice when choosing between the two.

Fitbit Blaze and  Surge Comparison Table

Fitbit Blaze Smart Fitness Watch, Black, Silver, Large
Fitbit Surge Fitness Superwatch, Black, Large (US Version)
Brand
Blaze
Surge
Display
Touchscreen
No Touchscreen
Display Technology
LED technology
OLED display
Activity Tracked
HRM, Sleep, Activity tracking, calories, No GPS, No swim tracking
HRM, Sleep, Activity tracking, calories, GPS, No-swim tracking
Heart Rate Monitor
Water Proof
Up to 10 meters ( 1 ATM)
Upto 50m (5 ATM)
Compatibility (OS supported)
Tizen-based wearable platform (iOS, Android, Window)
fitbitOS (iOS, Android)
Notification
All phone notifications
Call and text notifications only
GPS
Battery Life
5 days
7 days
Charging Time
Roughly an hour from 0-100% battery
Roughly an hour from 0-100% battery
Charging Mode
Small docking cradle
Small charging cable
Music Control
Music playback
No music playback
Additional Features
FitStar App
GPS
Syncing
iOS, Android, Windows
iOS, Android
Box Content
Tracker, Charging cable, Manual
Tracker, Charging cable, Manual
Prime Benefits
Model
Fitbit Blaze Smart Fitness Watch, Black, Silver, Large
Brand
Blaze
Display
Touchscreen
Display Technology
LED technology
Activity Tracked
HRM, Sleep, Activity tracking, calories, No GPS, No swim tracking
Heart Rate Monitor
Water Proof
Up to 10 meters ( 1 ATM)
Compatibility (OS supported)
Tizen-based wearable platform (iOS, Android, Window)
Notification
All phone notifications
GPS
Battery Life
5 days
Charging Time
Roughly an hour from 0-100% battery
Charging Mode
Small docking cradle
Music Control
Music playback
Additional Features
FitStar App
Syncing
iOS, Android, Windows
Box Content
Tracker, Charging cable, Manual
Prime Benefits
Fitbit Surge Fitness Superwatch, Black, Large (US Version)
Brand
Surge
Display
No Touchscreen
Display Technology
OLED display
Activity Tracked
HRM, Sleep, Activity tracking, calories, GPS, No-swim tracking
Heart Rate Monitor
Water Proof
Upto 50m (5 ATM)
Compatibility (OS supported)
fitbitOS (iOS, Android)
Notification
Call and text notifications only
GPS
Battery Life
7 days
Charging Time
Roughly an hour from 0-100% battery
Charging Mode
Small charging cable
Music Control
No music playback
Additional Features
GPS
Syncing
iOS, Android
Box Content
Tracker, Charging cable, Manual
Prime Benefits

Design

At the most basic level, the design between the two fitness trackers is the same. They both feature a similar layout comprising of three button-one on the left and two on the right, plus a touchscreen for navigational purposes.

However, beyond the core design similarities, the two fitness trackers are entirely different pieces.

The Fitbit Blaze also doubles up as an aesthetic accessory. Featuring a polished silver frame which hosts the square tracker and its touchscreen, the slimmer Blaze is by far fashionable and frankly more chic than other activity trackers.

The angular steel frame, with a bold finish, does an excellent job of fluidly blending with the rest of the activity tracker.

Though FitBit has frequently downplayed the idea of comparing the Blaze with Apple Watch, the Blaze is on many levels comparable to the Apple Watch including size and design. Is it appealing as the Apple Watch? Definitely no, but it`s a massive step towards the right direction, shaking off the sportier competitors within its class.

Again, besides size and design, and much like the Apple Watch, users of Blaze will enjoy variety in band colors and materials as the Blaze is designed to utilize other third-party bands available on Amazon. All you will have to do is pop-off the body and snap the activity tracker into a different strap.

Here, unlike the Surge, which works with flip-flops and tailored suits, the Blaze is versatile enough to be worn all day for different events from the office, gym, church, and even on the run without necessarily looking out of place.

Now let`s shift gears to the Surge. Despite being dubbed as Fitbit's fitness super watch, it`s evident that its design is inspired by the look and feel of some of the earlier Fitbit's fitness trackers.

Sporting a one-piece design and curves that will merrily contour around your wrist, the Surge makes up for an all-day activity tracker if you please. However, it`s not aesthetically appealing and stylish compared to the Blaze.

At the core of the Surge is a monochrome display screen. Though it`s not flashy and does not feature pop up colors, it`s excellent for preserving and extending the battery life, which we shall look later on.

The lack of a removable strap means that you will not get any customization beyond choosing your right color at the time of purchase. As such, you will have to think critically of which color to go with since you will get stuck with it for the entirety. Fortunately, the blue, black and tangerine color options will cater to both the bold, as well as the subdued look.

When it comes to design, it seems that FitBit is positioning the Blaze as the everyday watch for individuals who are looking for a stylish, and pragmatic fitness tracker.

Conversely, the Surge is promoted as a fitness super watch for the serious athletes who prefer a more utilitarian piece.


Fitbit Surge Fitness Superwatch, Black, Large (US Version)
  • GPS Tracking- See distance, pace and elevation climbed & review routes and split times
  • Get continuous, automatic, wrist-based heart rate and simplified heart rate zones
  • Track workouts & view workout summaries; plus all day activities including steps, distance, calories burned, floors climbed and active minutes
  • Monitor your sleep automatically and wake with a silent alarm
  • See call and text notifications on the touchscreen display

Display

As for the display, the Blaze features a colored a 1.25-inch LED screen display covered by Gorilla Glass 3. It`s, in fact, the first FitBit activity tracker with a color display. The living and color on the Blaze is supposedly amazing, while the Surge features a monochrome display. While the Blaze`s touchscreen is hardly HD, the 240 * 180 color resolution paves the way for sharpness, crispness, and clarity.

For the Blaze, the colors pop up nicely at the set black background when you reach your performance goals. The color animations feel appropriately over-the-top as well as wonderfully celebratory.

But don`t let the excitement get better of you; the display will not allow you to load any apps, meaning that the 1.25-inch color screen is more of an aesthetic feature.  While the screen is a cool and exciting feature, it`s pretty useless.

The Surge, on the other hand, features a dull and bland monochrome OLED display that display the time and all your performance statistics. Though the 1.25-inch OLED screen pales to that of Blaze, it makes a perfect option for a running watch.

Since the screen on the Surge in non-touch, navigation is done using the three buttons. The single button on the left is used for toggling between daily stats and sports function, while the two buttons on the right are for selecting inputs.

When it comes to the display, the Blaze offers a colorful, attractive interface with full of life. On the flip side, the Surge offers a robust and tough display that will stand up to whatever you throw at it including the tough, sweaty or dusty workouts.

If time and stopwatches are essential to you, the Surge is a perfect option since the display is always on and does not "sleep" meaning you can quickly glance at the time regardless the position of your hand. With the Blaze, the screen goes off after a period, and it`s quite frustrating for exercises that require a bit of timing.

For instance, if you`re doing a plank where each rep is based on a minute having the screen go off on the Blaze is an annoyance since you will have to break your plank to activate the screen to view the time.

It`s frustrating when you cannot simply look at your watch and tell what time it is, and perhaps this is why the Surge is dubbed the “Super Watch.”

Software and Apps

Connectivity is of the essence on any wearable device as it determines how well it can work with your smartphone or computer.

For the fitness trackers, connectivity to a plethora of devices from your smartphone to heart rate sensors is crucial.

The Fitbit Blaze is more inclined to smartwatches, and as such, it will provide you with more advanced connectivity as well as a greater number of supported options.

Both of these activity trackers sync wirelessly to most of the Smartphones and computers to transfer data. They allow you to upload a variety of performance activities onto the Fitbit app.

However, as we mentioned earlier, the Blaze leans towards the smarts, and it will allow you to receive all the phone notifications including calls, texts, emails, calendar event, and other notifications. On the other hand, the Surge is more basic, and will only provide you with the calls and text notifications.

Besides not displaying emails, the Surge does not work with third-party apps, which is quite unfortunate.

As you have noticed, the Blaze strikes a balance between an activity tracker and a smartwatch. It provides the perfect balance to those who are looking for simple smart devoid of the complexity of a full smartwatch.

Activity Tracking

With regards to fitness tracking, both of these two fitness trackers are capable of tracking a variety of performance activities such as;

  • Heart rate monitoring
  • Tracking steps
  • Sleep tracking
  • Activity tracking for popular exercises such as running, biking, weightlifting, and cycling

The biggest difference between the two is probably the GPS feature. The Fitbit Surge features a built-in GPS that allows accurate tracking of distances right on the watch. With the surge, you will no longer get hassled by carrying your iPhone to track your distance.

The GPS feature makes the Surge an ideal tracking option for the serious athletes as it allows tracking of your training progression. With a few swipes on the screen, the Surge can track all your steps.

Though the Blaze does not feature an onboard GPS, it can still track your distances through connected GPS. However, it will require you to carry your phone with you during the workouts.

To make up for the lack of GPS, the Blaze comes with the FitStar integration. This is a novel technology that supposedly functions as a personal trainer program. The program has incorporated three FitStar activities with the Blaze for free.

Besides the mentoring program, the Blaze also features a collection of quick, easy and efficient workouts that you can perform at home, at work, or even at the gym.

For the swimmers, you will get disappointed because both devices do not support the swim tracking unless you get alternative waterproof fitness watches for swimming. Despite the 5 ATM and 1 ATM waterproof of the Surge and Blaze respectively, FitBit does not recommend immersing the devices in water. However, you will not have to remove it when showering, washing utensils, or during a storm as it can perfectly stand up against splashes.


Sale
Fitbit Blaze Smart Fitness Watch, Black, Silver, Large
  • See simplified heart rate zones for quickly checking exercise intensity during workouts with PurePulse(TM) continuous, wrist-based heart rate monitoring (no uncomfortable chest strap required)
  • Use multi-sport tracking to track runs, cardio, cross-training, biking and more. Effortlessly and automatically record other workouts to your dashboard with SmartTrack
  • Enable connected GPS to map your routes and see run stats like pace and duration on display (when your phone is nearby)
  • Track steps, distance, calories burned, floors climbed and active minutes. Stay connected with call, text & calendar alerts and notifications from your favorite apps like Gmail, Facebook and more (when phone is nearby).Start a FitStar workout on your wrist and get step-by-step instructions and graphics to ensure you complete each move correctly

Accuracy

If you are wondering how accurate the GPS metrics are form the Surge, you are likely to notice that the results are fairly similar for separate sessions over the same distance and route. When viewed over a map layout, you will notice that the Surge does a decent job of tracking your route and distance traveled.

There are times, however, when the GPS seems a tad wonky, especially when starting out your sessions. This is because, at the beginning of the session, the GPS might have locked your position, but it cannot pinpoint where you are. Therefore, it`s always advisable that you wait for the GPS to lock you, and then give it 20-30 seconds before starting your session.

On the other hand, the FitStar program on the Blaze does a remarkable job of training as well as coaching you. The app, which features a multitude of short workouts allows you to perform basic exercises at your convenience without needing expensive equipment,

Additional Features

Besides the color display on the FitBit Blaze, this activity tracker also features a FitStar training program, which allows users to personalize their training.

The music function on the Blaze is also a distinctive feature that makes the device truly enjoyable to use.

Though the GPS is not novel and is a standard feature among many activity trackers, it`s a huge win for the athletes who wants a GPS Watch for tracking their running activities and  their steps accurately.

The inactivity alerts on the Surge are also crucial for always keeping you on your feet in your quest for optimal performance.

For both of the devices, users will appreciate the silent alarm feature. Rather than ringing, these activity band will vibrate gently without startling you.

Battery Life

The Fitbit Blaze provides a battery life of up to 5 days and night without needing to charge. Unlike the Surge, the Blaze comes with a color screen, which will inevitably reduce the battery life, especially if it`s worn during the day and night.

On the other hand, Fitbit claims that Surge comes with an extended battery life of up to 7 days. However, reviews from the users are quite contradicting, with many users complaining that the Surge only manages to go 3 days without charging. The alleged 3-day battery life, however, is still a bargain, especially when the device is used heavily with the onboard GPS turned on.

With a more spend-thrift use of the of the GPS, you can get at least 5-6 days, which is not far to what you can achieve with the Blaze.

Verdict

Both of these devices have plenty they can offer.

The Blaze, for instance, is packed with fitness tracking features and a stylish new look. It offers versatility with regards to how it can be worn and offers training guidance for the optimal performance.

On the other hand, the Surge offers a robust fitness tracker that can support advanced tracking using the built-in GPS.

However, each of the fitness trackers is rife with compromises. With the Blaze, you get a tracker that fancies itself as a smartwatch, but ultimately lacks the functionality of the true and leading smartwatches. This is in addition to lacking onboard GPS function.

Conversely, though the Surge offers an onboard GPS, you will have to do with a bulky and utilitarian experience.

If I were to choose between the two, I go with Blaze as we feel it`s an updated and cheaper version of the Surge.  Though it lacks on GPS, it offers more styles, more features, and excellent display.

Which watch has impressed you? Click links below to get it


Sale
Fitbit Blaze Smart Fitness Watch, Black, Silver, Large
Fitbit - Health and Beauty
- $28.00